N.C. Supreme Court Reaffirms Discovery Guardrails and Rejects Unilateral Rule Expansions in Sessoms v. Toyota Motor Sales
In a landmark ruling issued August 14, 2026 (Sessoms v. Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc., No. 23PA25), the Supreme Court of North Carolina issued a decisive victory for corporate entities, clarifying fundamental procedural rules governing depositions and document requests.
As appellate counsel for the Defendants, Brooks Pierce successfully argued before the North Carolina Supreme Court. The resulting decision reversed the Court of Appeals in part and vacated a trial court discovery order that had improperly waived client objections and imposed unauthorized procedural requirements.
Key Legal Takeaways
No Pre-Deposition Protective Order Required for Rule 30(b)(6): The Supreme Court held that a corporate deponent does not need to file a motion for a protective order prior to a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition to preserve its objections to noticed topics. Objections are preserved by lodging them directly with the requesting party reasonably in advance of the deposition.
Strict Enforcement of Rule 30(b)(5) Deadlines: Requesting parties cannot unilaterally impose accelerated response windows on document requests served with deposition notices. Statutory timelines (objections due at least 7 days prior to deposition) control unless altered by mutual consent or court order.
No Unilateral Translation Burden: The Court of Appeals had previously adopted the majority approach established in other jurisdictions that producing parties cannot be compelled to create English translations of documents maintained solely in a foreign language. The Supreme Court declined review on that topic, preserving the earlier victory.
Why This Ruling Matters for Corporate Litigants
This decision curbs strategic overreach in complex civil litigation across North Carolina. By confirming that corporate entities retain their objections to 30(b)(6) deposition topics without the immediate expense of seeking protective orders, the Supreme Court restored balance to the Rule 30(b)(6) process. Furthermore, the Court emphasized that true discovery compliance relies on mutual engagement and meaningful meet-and-confer efforts rather than procedural gamesmanship.